11/17/2026
As America’s workforce ages, workers’ compensation and personal injury professionals face increasingly complex questions surrounding orthopedic injuries and medical causation. When an older employee suffers a workplace injury, determining whether the condition resulted from the incident, preexisting degeneration, or a combination of both can significantly affect claim outcomes.
For attorneys, claims adjusters, and insurance professionals, understanding these distinctions is essential to evaluating compensability, treatment necessity, and long-term disability.
The Impact of an Aging Workforce on Orthopedic Injuries
Americans are working later into their life, and with age comes an increased likelihood of degenerative musculoskeletal conditions. Common examples include osteoarthritis, degenerative disc disease, rotator cuff deterioration, meniscal degeneration, and spinal stenosis.
Many of these conditions develop gradually and may remain asymptomatic for years. However, a workplace incident can trigger symptoms or aggravate an underlying condition, making it difficult to distinguish a new injury from preexisting pathology.
The presence of age-related degeneration does not automatically mean an injury is unrelated to work. Conversely, experiencing pain immediately after an incident does not necessarily establish that the event caused every abnormality identified during an orthopedic evaluation.
Why Determining Medical Causation Is Challenging
Consider a 60-year-old employee who experiences shoulder pain after lifting heavy equipment. An MRI reveals a rotator cuff tear accompanied by chronic tendon degeneration.
Did the lifting incident cause a new tear? Did it aggravate an existing tear? Or did it simply make a previously asymptomatic condition painful?
These questions are central to orthopedic injury causation and cannot always be answered through imaging alone.
MRI findings frequently reveal degenerative changes in individuals without symptoms. A thorough causation assessment must consider the reported mechanism of injury, prior medical history, physical examination, imaging findings, and progression of symptoms.
Aggravation vs. Natural Degeneration
One of the most disputed issues in workers’ compensation claims involves distinguishing an aggravation of a preexisting condition from its natural progression.
For example, an employee with lumbar degenerative disc disease may develop significant back pain following a workplace lifting incident. An orthopedic evaluation can help determine whether the event caused a new structural injury, temporarily exacerbated symptoms, or materially worsened the underlying condition.
These distinctions may influence medical treatment, impairment ratings, and claim resolution. However, the legal standards governing preexisting conditions and compensability vary by jurisdiction.
The Value of Independent Medical Evaluations
As orthopedic claims become more complicated, independent medical evaluations (IMEs) play an important role in clarifying medical causation.
An experienced orthopedic IME physician can independently assess medical records, diagnostic imaging, examination findings, and the reported injury mechanism to address critical questions:
- Is the diagnosed condition consistent with the workplace incident?
- What evidence supports preexisting degeneration?
- Did the incident cause a new injury or aggravate an existing condition?
- Is the proposed treatment medically necessary and related to the reported injury?
- Has the employee reached maximum medical improvement (MMI)?
A well-supported IME provides objective medical insight that helps attorneys, adjusters, and other stakeholders make informed decisions.
The Bottom Line: Age Alone Does Not Determine Causation
As older employees remain active in the workforce, orthopedic injury claims involving degenerative conditions will continue to present challenges.
Neither a worker’s age nor evidence of preexisting degeneration should automatically determine whether an injury is work-related. Accurate medical causation requires a comprehensive assessment of the clinical evidence and the relationship between the incident and diagnosed condition.
For workers’ compensation and personal injury professionals, a thorough, objective orthopedic evaluation can provide valuable clarity, reduce disputes, and support fair, informed claim resolution.
Schedule an appointment with Fox Valley Orthopedics today and get started on your journey getting back to the things you love!